Why Your Website Isn’t Working (And How to Fix It): Lead Generation Strategy for Real Estate Websites That Actually Works
You log into your CRM and get that little dopamine hit. “You’ve got a lead!” it says.
They searched for homes under $500K. They favorited one. They clicked around. Your IDX site is working… right?
Except, when you call them (energy and all), they say: “Um… who is this again?”
Oof.
If you’re a real estate agent and your lead generation strategy for real estate websites is basically “let them search for homes and hope they call me,” I hate to break it to you—but your website might be working against you.
Let’s change that.
Lead Generation Strategy for Real Estate Websites: Why IDX Feeds Don’t Build Trust (They Just Track Clicks)
Here’s the cold, hard truth:
Your IDX site doesn’t convert because it doesn’t connect.
When someone lands on a home search page, they’re looking for a house—not for you. So when you cold call them later, they’re confused. Maybe even a little creeped out.
It’s not your fault. It's how these platforms are set up.
In fact, the National Association of REALTORS® reports the average conversion rate for those kinds of leads is somewhere between 0.5% and 1.2%. That’s like 1 in 100—on a good day.
Let’s be honest: your IDX site makes the house the star. You? You're just the assistant holding the door open.
Maybe It’s Not the Leads… Maybe It’s Your Lead Generation Strategy for Real Estate Websites
The problem isn’t that there aren’t enough leads.
The problem is the way your website is positioned to capture them.
If you’re ready to stop being ghosted and start actually attracting leads who trust you before you even say “Hello,” you need to rethink your approach.
Here are three fixes you can make today to revamp your lead generation strategy for real estate websites.
Fix #1: Position Yourself Like a Shot of Tequila, Not a Cup of Tea
Positioning is everything.
If your homepage just screams “Look at my listings!” and shows a rotating slideshow of properties… yawn. That’s not connection. That’s a Zillow impersonation.
Instead, your site should say:
“Here’s who I help. Here’s how I help. And here’s why I’m different.”
Be specific. Speak directly to your ideal client:
Military families relocating to your area
First-time homebuyers who don’t know where to start
Retirees downsizing and feeling overwhelmed
Clarity isn’t exclusion—it’s precision. Fair Housing is safe here. You're allowed to specialize, friend, and that will help you with your lead generation strategy for real estate websites.
Fix #2: Video Builds Trust Faster Than Any Search Bar
If IDX feeds are cold and robotic, video is warm and familiar.
Take Kevin, a REALTOR® in Maryland. He creates YouTube videos about everything from design trends to inherited homes. When people land on his website and see his videos, something amazing happens:
They binge-watch.
They trust him.
They choose him.
Because by the time they reach out, they feel like they already know him.
No more cold calls. No more “So… how long have you been in real estate?”
Just “I’ve seen your videos—can you help me?”
You don’t need to be perfect on camera. You just need to be present.
Fix #3: Use Lead Magnets That Speak to Real Problems
Nobody is trading their email address for a home search bar anymore. They can find that on Zillow without giving up their privacy.
What people will trade their email for is value.
Great lead magnets solve specific problems:
“How to Buy an Investment Property That Pays for Itself”
“Military Relocation Guide: What You Need to Know Before You PCS”
“Declutter Without Losing Your Mind (Or Your Memories)”
Here's a real example: My friend Peggy offered a free decluttering guide on her website. She posted a YouTube video, paired it with that lead magnet, and got 20 leads in 10 days.
That's the kind of thing that scales. And that’s the kind of lead generation strategy for real estate websites you’d want to follow.
I walk you through everything about lead generation strategy for real estate websites here. If you’re a visual learner, or just want to hear me say it with more sass and coffee energy, watch this video.
Lead Generation Strategy for Real Estate Websites: A Simple Funnel That Converts
Here’s the real magic:
Clear Positioning – Make your message resonate with your ideal client.
Lead Magnet – Offer something valuable in exchange for their email.
Video Content – Build trust before you even reach out.
Simple Squeeze Page – One page. One offer. No distractions.
That’s it. You don’t need an overly complicated funnel. You need clarity. When someone lands on your site, they should feel like, “Oh hey, this is for me.”
You’re not just attracting leads. You’re building a system that earns trust and invites real connection.
Want to See My Lead Generation Strategy for Real Estate Websites in Action?
I’ve created a video that walks you through how to build your lead magnet here.
Lead Generation Strategy for Real Estate Websites: Stop Chasing. Start Attracting.
If your real estate website is just a dressed-up MLS search bar, you’re losing the battle before it even starts.
But with a shift in strategy—positioning, trust-building video, and lead magnets that serve—you can turn your site into a 24/7 lead machine that doesn’t creep people out… or get ghosted.
You in?
Subscribe & Get a Free Training
Want more tips on how to implement your lead generation strategy for real estate websites? Subscribe to my newsletter and get free video training on how to generate leads with YouTube.
____________________________________________________________________________
Karin Carr has been a REALTOR® since 2005 and real estate coach since 2018. Her YouTube videos have garnered more than 3.5 million views. She loves teaching real estate agents how to find real estate leads in a way that doesn’t require buying them from big corporations looking to put you out of business, or posting on social media all day just hoping to get a few likes and a couple of comments.
YouTube is Karin’s best method for attracting paying clients who see her value and happily hire (and pay) her to represent them in a real estate transaction. Coaching REALTORS is her true passion though and that’s where she spends the majority of her time these days. Her signature program, Video Boss Agent Academy, has helped thousands of real estate agents and mortgage professionals build businesses they love that are actually profitable.
Karin is the best selling author of YouTube for Real Estate Agents - Learn how to get free real estate leads and never cold call again.